Redirect


This site has moved to http://economistsview.typepad.com/
The posts below are backup copies from the new site.

April 10, 2013

'There Are No Grownups'

Paul Krugman:
Imaginary Grownups: So the Obama budget is out, Social Security cuts and all. Why is this happening?
Well, it’s all about the positioning. Ezra Klein gets at what I hear from the WH too (and what’s obvious in any case):
Today’s budget is the White House’s effort to reach the bedrock of the fiscal debate. Half of its purpose is showing what they’re willing to do. They want a budget compromise, and this budget proves it. There are now liberals protesting on the White House lawn. But the other half is revealing what the GOP is — or, more to the point, isn’t — willing to do. Republicans don’t want a budget compromise, and this budget is likely to prove that, too.
The question is, to whom are these things being “proved”?
Since the beginning, the Obama administration has seemed eager to gain the approval of the grownups — the sensible people who will reward efforts to be Serious, and eventually turn on those nasty, intransigent Republicans as long as Obama and co. don’t cater too much to the hippies. This is the latest, biggest version of that strategy. Unfortunately, it will almost surely fail. Why? Because there are no grownups..., the truth is that the “centrists” aren’t sincere. Calls for centrism and bipartisanship aren’t actual demands for specific policies — they’re an act, a posture these people take to make themselves seem noble and superior. And that posture requires blaming both parties equally, no matter what they do or propose. Obama’s budget will garner faint praise at best, quickly followed by denunciations of the president for not supplying the Leadership (TM) to make Republicans compromise — which means that he’s just as much at fault as they are, see? ... No, seriously (but not Seriously): who do you think could possibly be persuaded by this budget who hasn’t already been persuaded?
One quibble about "blaming both parties equally, no matter what they do or propose." I don't think the blame is equal. The (ahem) grownups begin with the assumption that they know what needs to be done. Deficits are bad, austerity is good, Social Security if bankrupt, disaster is just around the corner (unless we make good people suffer for the sins of others), and so on, and so on. They know all of these things despite the considerable evidence saying they are wrong, and this means they begin with a bias that causes them to lean toward the GOP's positions on many issues (which contributes to a rightward drift).

No comments: